Yellow light vs white light in fog

One general view about yellow vs white light in fog is based on the theory that scattering, by anything at all, is always greater at the short-wavelength end of the visible spectrum than at the long end. It must be true because the nineteenth-century British scientist Lord Rayleigh showed this in his paper of 1871 on the dispersion of electromagnetic radiation. This explained, amongst other things, why the sky is blue. This is because when the pure white light from the sun passes through the gases and extremely small particles in the atmosphere it’s scattered. Blue, and violet, light is dispersed the most because they travel as much shorter waves. So, the sky looks blue.

 

You’d assume therefore to get the greatest penetration of light through fog, you should use the longest wavelength possible. Red, being the longest, is obviously unsuitable however because it is used for traffic stoplights. So, you compromise and use yellow light instead.

 

This view is flawed though when it comes to light penetrating through fog. Rayleigh scattering – as it’s known – applies only to ‘scattering’ particles that are smaller than the wavelength of light and at wavelengths far from absorption. Fog droplets are huge compared with the wavelengths of visible light. This means that the scattering of light by fog is essentially wavelength independent. See Reference Articles 1 below.

 

We don’t need to consult scientific papers to understand this is true though. Just look at cars on the road at night. Designers of vehicle headlights have known for a long time that there is no magic colour that gives greater fog penetration. That’s why most headlights are white and why, for example, EU regulations require all new vehicles to have white lights. See Reference Articles 2 below.

 

So, for light penetration and perception in fog, the colour of light is unimportant. Yellow light. White light. There’s no difference.

 

Reference Articles 1

Bohren C. F, & Fraser A. (1985) – Colours of the Sky in The Physics Teacher pp 267-272. And Bohren, C. F. & Huffman, D. R. (1998) – Particles Small Compared with the Wavelength, in Absorption and Scattering of Light by Small Particles, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Weinheim, Germany.

 
Reference Articles 2

Nelson, J.H. (1938) – Optics of headlights in The Journal of Scientific Instruments Vol. XV, pp. 317-322. Also see the more recent Schreuder, D. A. (1976) – White or yellow light for vehicle head-lamps? In the Dutch Institute for Road Safety Research SWOV.

 
 

Upgrading to LED Floodlights using existing Masts: Considerations

Enhancing the sustainability of apron lighting systems: a simple guide for procurement officers

Do we need to change our electrics or cabling for LED floodlights?

See More From These Topics

Share this entry